Wednesday, September 17, 2014

Usability and HIT: Evolution and a Brief History of Cell Phones

By Joe Wivoda, Chief Information Officer

All week I have been using a cellular phone analogy for Health IT. I stated a couple of times that we are in the “bag phone” stage of HIT: bulky, unreliable, difficult to use and not very appealing. Our electronic health records (EHRs) and patient portals, it could be argued, are in the same state. At least I hope so. It can be somewhat comforting to think about what happened with cellular phone technology. From bag phone to iPhone, the evolution has been astounding. But also remember that cellular technology is a consumer product with an enormous market, and this evolution still took thirty years or more.

Consider how far we have come with EHRs in the last 10 years, however. It was common to have terminal-based (“green screen”) EHRs not that many years ago, and these were primarily billing and lab systems. Thanks partially to Meaningful Use, EHRs are commonly implemented with computerized physician order entry (CPOE), patient portals, radiology, clinical decision support, and all sorts of other safety or productivity features. Unfortunately, we hear more and more that the EHR is not user-friendly or that productivity has decreased for some users.

I did say “some users.” Other users of EHRs report significant improvement and would never go back to paper. Consider billing and lab for a moment. EHRs started out as billing systems for the most part, and although they are still not perfect, we hear much less from billing departments about usability. Similarly with lab, since lab was the next area to be automated, the EHRs have gone through an evolution of usability and functionality. The same will happen in nursing and provider documentation, but when?

It is really up to the users of EHRs to work with the vendors to improve their systems. We are the “environmental stimulus” in the evolution of EHRs. How do you communicate ideas and suggestions to your vendor? What process does your vendor have for listening and using your input? Do you have a cohort of similar facilities that has a stronger voice? Particularly in rural and with EHR vendors focused on rural, working with a cohort of similar facilities carries much more weight. Talk with your friends and see what their issues are, I bet you have some of the same ideas!

It is easy for me to say, “be patient, this is a normal part of the evolution of technology.” I don’t have to use EHRs every day! There are ways to speed up the evolution, with government regulation (Meaningful Use), customer pressure (suggestions and feedback), and market forces (have you seen how many mergers are occurring?). Remember when Nokia was hailed for its innovation when they came out with cell phones that had a choice of colors? Then the iPhone happened. If you have an EHR, do this today:

  • Use the test system to understand how documentation workflows can be modified
  • Think about all the steps in those workflows, not just the number of clicks or screen changes. Is there a better workflow? Flow chart it!
  • Consider what information would be useful to have at each step in the process. Don’t think in terms of the paper-based ways that have existed for 100 years; think about the basic information you need.
  • Keep looking for improvements and innovative ideas, the communicate those to the vendor 

We will get there. Evolution takes time, but we can help speed it along.

Tuesday, September 16, 2014

The Public Face of HIT: Patient Portals and PHRs

By Joe Wivoda, Chief Information Officer

This is my second blog for National HIT Week, or as we are spelling it on Twitter, #NHITWeek (shameless plug: follow me @WivodaRural and The Center too @RHRC). Yesterday’s blog was really an introduction and short discussion of the concept of a national week dedicated to Health Information Technology (HIT). So exciting! So many opportunities for me to opine! So many late nights behind the keyboard! This time I want to discuss an HIT topic that we can all participate in as consumers.

There is no more important HIT topic to me right now than patient engagement. We have such a great opportunity now to start engaging patients in their own care by providing them with the data and information that we have locked up in our newly-installed electronic health records. Just about every industry you can think of does a better job of providing information to their customers. My car company provides a portal for the health of my car. My Honeywell thermostat even notifies me if my house gets too cold. One of the most data-rich industries in the history of human kind is just now providing patients with access to their health information.

I often hear that rural has unique challenges with providing patient portals or personal health records (I think these are separate, and I will explain why later) for a variety of reasons:

  • “Our patients are older”
  • “We have poor broadband out here”
  • “Our patients just don’t want that information”

These things may indeed be true, but that doesn't mean that we shouldn't work hard to provide access to those patients and their caregivers. Older patients likely have family that are involved in their care, and that family may not be close by. Cellular technology is putting the internet into the hands of more people in more places than ever before. Even if your patients say they don’t want it today, they will very soon.

I said yesterday that we are in the “bag phone” era for HIT. When cell phones were new, there were large areas of countryside where trying to use your new phone made about as much sense trying to plug your laptop into a currant bush. It just wasn't going to work! Our model for providing patients with their health information is not much different: locked up in proprietary silos that make scheduling appointments easy, communicating with providers difficult, and functions for exporting your data into a universally accepted form (C-CDA) obscure. Personal Health Records (PHRs) like Microsoft HealthVault allow you to take the information from the various patient portals that you may have and import the data to one location. The beauty of these PHRs is that many national providers, like pharmacy chains, can automatically send information to these portals. Sadly, so can just about any local hospital, clinic, or healthcare system. The hookup is free, but few take advantage of it today. My healthcare provider knows I prefer my health information to be in a PHR of my choice and I will keep asking them to support that (someday, hopefully, please?).

What is your assignment for today? Go get access to your health information from your clinic, hospital, pharmacy, or other provider. Already have access and enjoy “checking your own oil”? Then talk to someone in your family and have them sign up. If you are responsible for the patient portal at a health care provider, is it user friendly? Does it allow patients to download their information easily? Is it easy to contact providers directly?

Soon patients will be demanding better access to their information. This patient does. So should you. Let’s move from the bag-phone era to the coveted flip-phone soon. Now that reminds me, I need to order an iPhone 6…

P.S. Cue the foreboding music! Tomorrow's topic is usability in HIT. Everyone has an opinion on that, send me yours @WivodaRural!

Monday, September 15, 2014

Welcome to National HIT Week!

By Joe Wivoda, Chief Information Officer

As a species we enjoy celebrating things. Birthdays (mine is November 28), anniversaries, National Joe Day (March 27th – you can call yourself Joe that day if you like), even National Sneak Some Zucchini onto Your Neighbors Porch Day (August 8). Today happens to be National Felt Hat Day, but more importantly for me, since felt hats make my head itch, it is the beginning of National Health IT Week! I haven’t been this excited since I found out there was a National Joe Day.

HIT is important to rural health care. HIT offers an opportunity to improve the health of the communities we serve, to improve the efficiency of the services we provide, and to improve the quality of the care that we provide. HIT has become an important fundamental technology, almost as fundamental as telephones or the lights. The infrastructure nature of HIT will become more obvious as health reform efforts move care from pay-for-volume to pay-for-quality in the next few years. It’s important to stop and consider how far we have come, and how far we have yet to go, in HIT.

What are you going to do for HIT week? Well, you don’t need to buy a present for your local HIT professional. Please don’t look for ways to make more work for your HIT person by deleting random files from your computer or violating HIPAA in such a way that an extensive privacy audit will need to be completed. I recommend the following:


  • If you are not signed up for your patient portal, do so!
  • If you have more than one patient portal because you see several providers and they do not share data, consider setting up a personal health record of your own (I use Microsoft HealthVault) and copy all of your data there.
  • Read this blog every day this week. There will be a new post each day about HIT. Sorry, shameless self-promotion is one of my weaknesses.
  • Look around at all the ways HIT is present in our community: hospitals, clinics, home care, long-term care, medical supply, pharmacy, school nurse, behavioral health provider, state corrections facility. These are all businesses that likely use significant HIT. Heck, in my small town of Hibbing, MN we have an HIT vendor (IRCS – they make behavioral health EHRs)!


Spend some time thinking about the future of HIT as well. We are in the “bag phone” stage of HIT. When cellular phone technology was first made available the phones were large, expensive, unreliable, and were presented in a less-than-stylish black canvas bag. Our current EHRs will seem silly and incomplete in five years, so consider what HIT will look like. I will be blogging on that later in the week, so feel free to comment with thoughts below or send me a tweet @WivodaRural.

Also, to celebrate HIT week, I just might have a whiskey over ice!

Friday, August 29, 2014

Perfect Patient vs Physician’s Pain in the A**: How Informed Patients can Lead the Way

by Kami Norland, MA, ATR, Community Program Manager

I have recently been on the hunt for a new primary care provider. My previous provider was fine. Her diagnostic assessments seemed accurate (as my self-assessments were verified from my personal WebMD and CDC searches—I know, I know, I can actually hear cringing and warnings to not self-diagnose from online sources as a hangnail could become fatal according to some websites). Despite my self-diagnosing tendencies, my provider appeared non-judgmental and trustworthy. However, her default mode of intervention was to prescribe a round of antibiotics and hurriedly move on to the next patient. During my time with her, there was no mention of how I could alleviate my ailments through nutrition, exercise or stress management. My visit lasted all of 10 minutes so she never really knew my name and when I left my appointment I spotted her in the back parking lot, lips pierced and lungs deeply inhaling on a thin roll of tobacco.

It was at that moment I realized that I needed to officially begin my search for a provider that was more in alignment with my needs and philosophies toward health. Admittedly, this is no easy task as I have exceptionally high standards for what good care looks like and should be as I travel across the country to small rural hospitals, conversing with the country’s finest physicians and leaders. I have witnessed effective leadership in health care and I know what it takes for a patient to receive high quality care focused on wellness. Top off this knowledge with a personal philosophy that could be rightfully classified as a “health nut” and you have the makings for either the perfect patient or a physician’s biggest pain in the a**.

I primarily conducted my physician search online, hopping from website to website. I held no real loyalty to my provider or the health system, other than wanting to assure that my electronic health records (EHR) could transfer to wherever I ended up. I read a plethora of physician profiles looking for someone who I could grow old with and who understood the value of focusing on wellness and quality of care. I narrowed my search down to two providers, one of which was a resident being overseen by the University Med School in town. Either provider seemed sufficient based on the short paragraph descriptions of their philosophy toward medicine and health, so I let the scheduling receptionist determine who I would see based on availability. 

An appointment with the resident was scheduled. During our first visit, I inquired about the resident’s knowledge of the Triple Aim (using my best “Minnesota nice” manners so as to not offend) and set forth my expectations of adhering to a wellness approach. To my surprise and glee, the resident was well informed and asked me questions about nutrition, exercise, stress management and the like. It was evident that she was also prepping me for completing a patient satisfaction survey as she simultaneously entered data into my transferred EHR. Bonus points were even given to my new physician when she later called me to follow up on my physical and emotional well-being from a small procedure.

In the coming era of value-based care, rural health facilities have the opportunity to be seen as transformational leaders in health care rather than just vendors of health services. Implementing this change from the volume- to the value-based model requires an extensive change in how health care is experienced by the patient and the provider. As the provider, it’s about asking the patient the right questions. As the patient, it’s about receiving the kind of care that extends beyond the hospital walls where we can be reassured that our physician not only knows our name but also helps us to stay healthy and out of the hospital.

I don’t think I’m alone in my inquiry and “demands” of seeking a provider who recognizes that the value-based model, one that focuses on wellness and population health, is the right approach to care. I also am not alone in utilizing online sources and being an informed consumer of health care. 

Providers, if you haven’t already experienced the grassroots movement of patients defining their expectations of wellness and value-based care, be prepared to make this transition.

Hospital leaders, prepare your board and staff for this transition by:

Monday, August 4, 2014

National Cooperative of Health Networks (NCHN) 2014 Annual Education Conference

By Kap Wilkes, MBA, Program Manager

There was a convergence of rural health leaders in St. Louis at the National Cooperative of Health Networks (NCHN) 2014 Annual Education Conference the week of June 16th. I had been getting ready for this conference for several months as I had the good fortune to be part of the conference planning committee. The volunteer group of planners spent a couple of hours a month together and a good number of hours on our own putting together the details; you can imagine how our time and focus increased as the date approached!

Over 125 rural health network leaders from a diverse variety of structures, types of members and network services came together to learn from each other. The highlight for me was to provide some of the content for the conference with my colleague, Joe Wivoda. We presented interactive and dynamic information on building meaningful and impactful collaborations, network sustainability using a systems framework, and using health information technology (HIT) for improved transitions of care.

There were many other learning opportunities at the Conference. More than five Rural Health Information Technology Network Development (RHITND) program grantees presented to their peers on topics like: implementing a rural health network care coordination service, creating a regional collaboration, making member’s health data meaningful for improvement and sustainability, network development strategic business planning, implementing an electronic population management tool as a network service and transforming member’s health care delivery through better use of data. All of these topics are opportunities for rural health networks to build their own infrastructure and capacity and to develop products and services that their members will value.

Another highlight of the conference was the Innovation Circles. We kicked off the conference by forming small groups to brainstorm and select eight topics that would be both relevant and pertinent for round table discussions; Innovation Circles, held later in the day. A cool thing happened; six Innovation Circles took place with robust discussions and meaningful exchange.

These Innovation Circles truly are incubators by bringing together smart, engaged people to share their experience, knowledge and expertise from diverse networks. This is a powerful equation for creativity and solutions. Some of the topics they discussed included:  Patient Engagement and Meaningful Use (MU) Patient Portal Development, Challenges of Care Coordination Across Networks and Systems, Challenges with Rural Staffing, Data Analytics: What and Then How to Measure and Challenges Sharing Health Information Across Uncommon Electronic Health Record (EHR) Platforms. My observation was that those who participated in the Innovation Circles and the education opportunities throughout the conference took away fresh insights, deeper knowledge and new connections. The impact of the NCHN Conference will be ripples of innovation and solutions across our country, and the outcome will be more wellness in our communities!

Friday, August 1, 2014

Small Doesn’t Have to be Small

By Rhonda Barcus, Program Specialist

Recently, I had the good fortune of attending the National Rural Health Association (NRHA) 10th Annual Rural Quality and Clinical Conference in Atlanta, Georgia. I stepped off the plane to a cool 61 degrees. Now mind you, this is the middle of July in Atlanta! This was just the first in a number of unexpected pleasures for the day.

My second nice surprise came from the comradery of the folks attending. What a nice way to start the day with my friends from Alabama, including Rural Hospital Performance Improvement (RHPI) Project state partners, Jane and Bethany, and our friends from Jackson Medical Center, Jennifer and Angela. It is always a treat to spend time with such positive and motivated colleagues who continue to care and strive for the best. Thanks for letting me sit at your table even though I’m not official Alabama! It was nice to share the time with Mary Guyot from Stroudwater Associates as well.

For me, the big take-away from the conference came from a presentation by John Worden, PharmD, MS, BCPS, the Pharmacy and Laboratory Services Director at McPherson Hospital in Kansas. He discussed the amazing things that rural is capable of and that “small doesn’t have to be small.” He shared a concept that he uses with the hospital pharmacy—to run his department as an “enterprise.” He works to think Big and lead Big and to really focus on being at the forefront of innovation rather than waiting to be told what needs to be done. Along those lines, he pointed out that “rural is an entrepreneur’s dream” because the opportunities are endless, and it’s important for those working in rural to think in this way.  

A second outstanding point from Dr. Worden’s presentation involved the change in practice as a result of change in health care. He shared that pharmacists are no longer just “dispensing pills,” but it is now about putting professionals at the bedside. Pharmacists are now intimately involved in patient education, which affects discharge planning, medication compliance and ultimately readmission rates and Hospital Consumer Assessment of Healthcare Providers and Systems (HCAHPS) numbers. This change in health care is really exciting for rural since there is already a history of relationships with patients and the community. He shared his concept of “high touch service” that really encourages and supports that one-on-one relationship with the patient.

The quality conference really was a reminder to me that the BIG things really are the small things…an unexpected cool day, time with good people, a reminder of the many opportunities in rural and the importance of relationships. Oh, and how can I forget…the warm chocolate chip cookies!

Thursday, July 31, 2014

What is Driving Health IT Right Now?

By Joe Wivoda, Chief Information Officer

WARNING: The following is a rant and a plea for a change in direction in health information technology (HIT). I would love to hear what others think. What drives us in HIT? Is it regulation, the vendors, the patients, or quality? 

The Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) just closed the comment period for the Notice of Proposed Rulemaking (NPRM) for the Meaningful Use Stage 2 delay. For many of us the biggest question about the NPRM is what does "implementation" mean in the rule? Does it mean that if the vendor is charging a ridiculous amount for the 2014 version, and we found out after the budget process was complete, we have a delay in implementation? We spend so much time thinking about ways to simplify our lives, whether it is taking advantage of a proposed rule, filing for an exception, or implementing the "low hanging fruit" of the meaningful use menu objectives. I asked myself "What is really driving us in health IT?" Or, more importantly, "What should be driving us?"

Prior to the economic collapse and subsequent American Recovery and Reinvestment Act (ARRA) of 2009, HIT was focused primarily on making incremental improvements and slowly implementing clinical systems. The "stimulus" and associated HiTECH Act provided significant impetus to hospitals and clinics (but not elder care, homecare, hospice, behavioral health, the list goes on) to fully implement and adopt electronic systems in health care. Further, money was allocated to support this effort in the form of the regional extension program and workforce development. These steps certainly moved the needle, and as of today we have 93% of hospitals that have received payment for Meaningful Use!

Achieving Meaningful Use does not necessarily mean you are effectively utilizing an electronic health record (EHR), or even that you are using it properly, but the Office of the National Coordinator for Health Information Technology (ONC) and CMS have steadily made improvements to the requirements such that we are being forced to use EHRs to benefit patients. I see so much complaining and hand-wringing over the Stage 2 requirements around patient engagement and transitions of care, even before attempts were made to reach the measures! Is it really that painful and difficult to get 5% of our patients to look at their health information electronically? Shouldn't we agree that electronically sending summaries of care for patients transferred to other facilities is the right thing to do for ALL patients, not just 10%?

I do agree there are barriers to achieving the Stage 2 objectives, but they can be overcome. Vendor performance is probably the most difficult to overcome, and that is the purpose of the NPRM that allows hospitals and clinics to delay Stage 2 or even go back to 2013 Stage 1 measures this year (assuming it goes through). We need to break the cycle of talking about how we need to implement technology, bring up barriers, react to legislation of finances, and finally make incremental changes. Those of us who work in health IT need to stop making decisions based primarily on what the government or the payers say: We need to listen to the patients!

If we focus on patient safety, patient satisfaction and quality measurement, we will not have any problem meeting the requirements for Meaningful Use or payment reform. Stage 3 of Meaningful Use will likely require even more patient engagement and quality measures, so why not focus on those now? We will improve the health of our communities and improve the financial stability of our organizations. I challenge all of my HIT colleagues to ask yourself these questions each day:

     "What am I working on that will improve the lives of people in my community?"
     "Are my priorities aligned with our patients?"
     "What information do we need to make real improvements in quality?"

Sure, we will still need to meet the requirements of Meaningful Use, ICD-10, the Chief Financial Officer, a cantankerous physician and others, but we need to do everything through a lens that focuses on patients and quality.

Now that I am done with my rant, I have to go see if the Stage 3 requirements came out yet...