Friday, August 24, 2012

Final Meaningful Use Stage 2 Rule Commentary--"Now Is the Time"

Joe Wivoda, Chief Information Officer

The final rule for Stage 2 of Meaningful Use came out August 23rd--earlier than expected and with few actual surprises. CMS took the public comments seriously and modified the proposed rule in many areas based on those comments. The final rule is released with commentary and is a full 672 pages long, and this overview is based on a quick review. More information will be available as we dig into the rule further.

Don't forget, this rule does not go into effect until 2014 at the earliest. If you attest to Meaningful Use Stage 1 you get two years to reach Stage 2, unless you attested in 2011, in which you get three years.

There is no reason to panic, you have time to understand the new rule, but there are some themes that are important to be aware of now.

Utilize Your EHR
The menu requirements for Stage 1 have, for the most part, been incorporated into core requirements in Stage 2. Many of the core requirements have higher thresholds under Stage 2. This means that you will need to utilize your EHR more. For example, in Stage 1 the CPOE requirement was that 30% of patients have at least one medication order. One could argue that if you met that requirement exactly, and no more, you would be operating in a less safe manner, since you now have multiple processes for the same tasks. The new rule for CPOE is that 60% of medication, 30% of lab, and 30% of radiology ORDERS need to be in CPOE.

Now is the time to understand the new core requirements and begin planning and redesigning workflows to meet them.

Information Exchange
Electronically transmitting information for transitions of care for 10% of care transitions is a new requirement for Stage 2. The work that is being done on HIEs today will create the infrastructure for these transmissions, but more work will need to be done. Since so many hospital discharges are to long term care (LTC) facilities, hospitals will need to work with them to participate in the HIE. LTC does not receive any incentives for Meaningful Use, and many LTC EHRs are not prepared to exchange information today (though some are).

Now is the time to consider your referral patterns and engage those providers to begin planning for information exchange.

Patient Engagement
Under Stage 1 providers only needed to provide electronic information to patients when they asked for it, and then providers were only required to provide it 50% of the time. Stage 2 will require hospitals and eligible professionals to not only provide the information, but it also requires that 5% of patients access their information through a portal. There is also a requirement that 5% of patients are communicated with using secure messaging. There are exclusions for areas that have limited Internet connectivity, but almost all providers will need to meet these requirements.

Now is the time to talk with your vendor about their portal offerings, or if they can interface with a Personal Health Record (PHR), and begin planning how you will engage patients to actively view their information online.

Clinical Quality Measures
The requirements for Clinical Quality Measure reporting in Stage 1 were fairly easy, although the measures did not necessarily apply well to rural facilities. The new rule provides many more options for reporting and electronic submission will be required. More information will be available about the quality measures that you can choose from.

Now is the time to speak with your vendor to make sure that the reports you think are most appropriate are incorporated into the Stage 2-certified version of your EHR.

Some Changes to Stage 1
There are some changes to Stage 1 requirements that go into effect in 2013 and 2014. Many are additional exclusions. For example, if you can demonstrate that collecting some vitals are not part of the scope of your practice (e.g. Chiropractor), then you do not need to meet the objective of collecting vitals. The requirement of exchanging clinical information will be removed in 2013, but since the Stage 2 exchange requirements are so important, you cannot put off work on the exchange requirements.

Now is the time, if you have questions about those exclusions, to understand the changes to Stage 1.

Conclusion
The new Stage 2 rules for Meaningful Use have only been out for a few hours, and for the most part do not go into effect until 2014 at the earliest. This provides time to fully understand the rules and begin discussions with your vendors, referral partners, patients, HIE, and other stakeholders to properly prepare to meet the rules. The purpose of these new rules is to encourage health care providers to utilize electronic systems to be more safe and efficient, and to improve quality. Information exchange between providers of care and providing relevant clinical information directly to patients electronically are important ways to achieve these goals.

More Information
CMS final rule
*
*
ONC standards and certification criteria final rule
*
*
More information on the Stage 2 rule
*
*

Wednesday, August 22, 2012

A Lot to Learn from the Last Frontier

Joe Wivoda, Chief Information Officer

Rural health care faces many challenges, such as workforce attraction and retention, geographic constraints, and the high cost of HIT.  These problems are magnified in Alaska.  With a population of less than 750,000 (47th in the US) and an average density of 1.2 people per square mile, it becomes clear why The Last Frontier presents so many challenges to health care (and I didn't even mention the winter weather).  As part of our Technical Assistance to Rural Health HIT Network Development grantees I was privileged to spend a few days in Alaska getting more acquainted with them and how they overcome some of the challenges to providing healthcare in this beautiful state.

With so much land area and low population density it is difficult to provide traditional access to health care.  Some clinics are hundreds of miles from a hospital, and with Alaska's unpredictable weather flying can be difficult.  The Alaska Native Tribal Health Consortium (ANTHC) has created a vast telemedicine network to support rural clinics.  During my visit with Richard Hall at ANTHC, I learned that they have been doing amazing work to bring primary care services to remote areas using HIT, while coordinating the efforts of several organizations to make it happen.

One of the organizations that ANTHC partners with is the Tanana Chiefs Conference.  I was able to spend the day with Jim Williams at Tanana Chiefs and visited the clinic in Nenana.  At the clinic I talked with a Community Health Aid/Practitioner (CHAP) that provides care to several patients each day.  The CHAP program was designed to overcome workforce shortages that exist in small villages across Alaska and consists of 16 weeks of training plus preceptorship and practicum.  I was impressed with the amount of telemedicine and telepharmacy that was in use at the clinic!

Alaska has a number of critical access hospitals that are located far from tertiary facilities.  The Alaska State Hospital and Nursing Home Association (ASHNHA) has formed a network of some of these smaller hospitals to "support the use of HIT as a tool to improve the quality and cost efficiency".  Like many other rural hospitals, these facilities struggle with finding HIT talent, and most of them have one IT person on staff with limited access to outside resources.  I spent a day with Jeannie Monk and spoke with the member CFOs about Meaningful Use and the financial incentives.  These hospitals are working closely with each other to find ways to share expertise and best practices, even though they are hundreds of miles apart in many cases.

Alaska is a vast, beautiful place.  The geography and size, along with a small population and cold winters, create significant challenges to providing health care to the native and non-native communities.  All three of the networks that I visited in June are doing amazing work to overcome these challenges.  There is much we can all learn from them.

Thursday, August 16, 2012

Health Reform, the Supreme Court and Networks—Finding Comfort in the Chaos

Sally Trnka, Senior Program Coordinator

(This content was originally published in Cooperative Connections Newsletter)
Raise your hand if you are exhausted from the never ending news coverage, heated campaign promises, and scores of misinformation being broadcast pertaining to health care reform.  (It’s okay…go ahead!)  The complexities and confusion surrounding the recent Supreme Court decision aren’t lost on anyone and the confusion is compounded by election-year rhetoric and posturing that dismantles communication and banishes progress.  Since we’re not running for office, we’ll give it to you direct—and with a sprinkling of enthusiasm for the role of rural health networks in the changing healthcare landscape.  
The 5-4 Supreme Court ruling upholding the Affordable Care Act determined that the individual mandate, the most controversial part of the ACA, was a valid exercise in Congress’s power to tax (although it is not a valid exercise of the Commerce Clause, which was the clause that many opponents were expecting would deem the mandate unconstitutional).  In addition to upholding the policies and provisions that are scheduled to take effect in the coming years, the ruling solidified that the money, payment modifications and workforce modifications that have already gone into effect will not be rescinded. 
Okay, so that much you know, but what does all of this mean for rural?  There are a variety of rural-specific provisions within the ACA that will move forward as scheduled because of the ruling.  A compressive list of the rural-relevant provisions can be found on the website of the National Rural Health Association (NRHA).  Because it’s a long list, we’ll walk through a few of them, and why they are critical to the success of rural health care facilities. 
Approximately 25% of the country’s population resides in rural areas however, there are more rural Americans who are uninsured and underinsured than their urban counterparts.[1] The ACA contains provisions for the guaranteed issue and coverage renewability, along with the prohibition of exclusions based on pre-existing conditions.  This will help to ensure that more citizens are covered.  Increased coverage, however, does not equal access and workforce shortages will continue to be felt acutely in rural communities.  Currently, less than 10% of physicians serve the country’s rural population and with increased insurance coverage, the strain felt by providers will be even greater.  Included in the ACA are investments in the National Health Service Corps which will assist medical students with scholarships and loan repayment programs should they decide to practice in rural communities.  The ACA also designates critical access hospitals, for the first time, eligible sites for Corps assisted physicians.  The ACA also calls for increased funding for Area Health Education Center’s (AHEC) to improve the pipeline of potential future health care leaders, although the House of Representatives recently voted AHEC out of the running for funding for next year.  (Hopefully the Senate will reinstate funding.)  The improvement in the rural healthcare workforce will be vital to support the higher rates of chronic disease exhibited in rural communities[2].  With an increased focus on primary care and prevention, the ACA incentivizes patients to seek care before their condition becomes chronic or requires treatment from a specialist. 
Networks will play a crucial role in all of the health reform models as rural providers and hospitals become valuable players in both accountable care organization (ACO) and Medical Home demonstration projects.  The development and participation in ACO and the Medical Home concept all require collaboration, staff and resource sharing, collective innovation, and willingness to challenge the status quo.  Increasingly, rural hospitals will have to prepare themselves for a challenging future, based on value, quality transparency, and physician-hospital partnerships while maintaining a successful business model in the current system.  It’s is somewhat like navigating two canoes downstream with a leg in each canoe…it could end up being very painful!


[1] Lenardson, J., Ziller, E., Coburn, A. & Anderson, N. Profile of Rural Health Insurance Coverage: A Chartbook. Rural Health Research and Policy Centers. June 2009. 
[2] Glasgow, N., Johnson, N., Morton, L. Critical Issues in Rural Health. Wiley-Blackwell. May 2004. 

A special thank you to the National Rural Health Association for their breakdown of the rural-relevant provisions in the ACA. 

Monday, July 23, 2012

Medicare Meaningful Use Incentives: A Confusing Minefield for Critical Access

Joe Wivoda, Chief Information Officer

Critical access hospitals (CAH) need to be aware of what is eligible for Medicare Meaningful Use incentives, and it can be confusing. Sure, we need to purchase a certified electronic health records (EHR), but the incentives for Medicare specify that CAHs can get a portion of the "reasonable costs" of acquiring certified technology. There are several catches (just read the FAQ 10163 and you will see what I mean). Here are some very important considerations when signing a contract for an EHR, whether from a vendor or a larger hospital system offering a great deal on their system.

A Right To Use Agreement is the most common contract for an EHR, at least historically. This type of agreement is similar to what you get when you purchase office software, such as from Microsoft. Surprisingly, you do not technically "own" the software in this case (or any that I will talk about). You merely have a right to use the software. These agreements generally also state that you lose that right to use the software if you quit paying the annual support and maintenance fees. One of the secrets in the software industry (not just health care) is that vendors make money on the maintenance agreement, not necessarily the licensing agreement. This is why vendors will usually negotiate aggressively on the licensing fee, but not on the maintenance. Even though you don't own the software, the right to use licensing agreement fees (not the maintenance fees - those are non-capital) are usually a capital expense and thus eligible for CAH Meaningful Use incentives from Medicare.

If you choose to lease the software over a period of time, then things get a little more tricky. Thankfully, the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) recently clarified what is a qualified expense in FAQ 10722. Leasing can make sense if the hospital can not afford the licensing fees up front. Many vendors offer leasing packages as an option when that final contract is delivered. However, an Operating Lease is not depreciable, and therefore not eligible for Meaningful Use incentives. Capital Leases are eligible expenses, and it is important that you understand the difference. One of the four following conditions must be met for the purchase to be a capital lease:
  • The lease transfers title of the facilities or equipment to the lessee during the lease term,
  • The lease contains a bargain purchase option,
  • The lease term is 75 percent or more of the useful life of the facilities or equipment. This provision is not applicable if the lease begins in the last 25 percent of the useful life of the facilities or equipment, or
  • The present value of the minimum lease payments (that is, payments to be made during the lease term, including bargain purchase option, guaranteed residual value, or penalties for failure to renew) equal 90 percent or more of the fair market value of the leased property. This provision is not applicable if the lease begins in the last 25 percent of the useful life of the facilities or equipment. The present value is computed using the lessee's incremental borrowing rate, unless the interest rate implicit in the lease is known and is less than the lessee's incremental borrowing rate, in which case, the interest rate implicit in the lease is used.
I am not an accountant. Or a CPA. Or a CFO. Or a Medicare Administrative Contractor (MAC). I suggest you talk to one of them to be certain!

"Cloud Computing" is a trend in Information Technology (I hate the term "cloud computing" by the way - it sounds too magical). Software as a Service (SaaS) is another term for this type of software delivery. Basically, the equipment is housed somewhere besides your facility, in a secured data center. This type of "software delivery" is becoming more common now that high-speed Internet is more readily available. Is this type of agreement eligible for incentive dollars? Think about it: You don't own the hardware, or the software, and you usually pay a monthly fee to use it. That is a clear operating expense, not depreciable, and not eligible for Meaningful Use incentives under the Medicare rules for CAHs. These agreements often make sense: They are a reasonable expense, the implementation costs are usually low or nonexistent (since there is little customization allowed), the hospital does not need to worry about backups or having a Unix geek (like me) on staff, etc. These reasons may offset the value of the incentives, actually! Also, some vendors are structuring the agreements so that you CAN receive some incentives. If you are considering entering into this kind of agreement, ask questions about whether you can still receive Medicare incentives. Also ask about security, reliability, support, and a million other things that should be in another post...

Finally, all of these contract concerns apply when you are entering into an agreement with a larger hospital system. The key is whether or not the expenses are depreciable, and as a CIO, that is a term that I struggle to understand. Feel free to look at 42 CFR 413, or the Federal Accounting Standards Board (FASB) rules. For me, it's easier to understand the Theory of Special Relativity, but thanks to the CMS Frequently Asked Questions site I think I am starting to get it...

Friday, July 20, 2012

Minnesota Action Coalition: Support for the new health care delivery models



Last fall I was asked to join the Minnesota Action Coalition and while the title wasn’t specific to the type of action, I gathered that it would be focused on nursing as the recommendation came from one of The Center’s Board Officers the Dean of Nursing at The College of St. Scholastica. As I reviewed the materials, I discovered that the Action Coalition was developed to effect long-term changes to meet the Institute of Medicine (IOM) 2010 Recommendations on the Future of Nursing. The goal of the report is to “transform the nursing field to prepare nurses to lead change and advance health for all Americans.” The Action Coalition in Minnesota is just one of forty-eight nationwide and supported by the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation (RWJF) in cooperation with the American Association of Retired Persons (AARP) and the AARP Foundation. This partnership of a leading health foundation and AARP was surprising to me at first; however, I quickly realized, it was highly strategic union. The AARP brought strong technical assistance in advocacy and policy development to the state coalitions and RWJF is supporting the technical assistance instead of providing grant funds to the Action Coalitions.

The Future of Nursing Campaign for Action, which supports the Action Coalitions, is designed to transform the nation’s health care system so that all Americans have access to high quality, patient centered care where they live, work, learn and play across the lifespan. The Action Coalitions have committed to develop and implement specific strategies to address the IOM recommendations. These are not short term efforts such as increasing nursing class size through scholarships. The strategies need to address: scope of practice; higher levels of education and academic progression; leadership in the redesign of the healthcare system; and, workforce planning and policy making through data and information. Any of these areas alone would entail a challenge to states let alone tackling all four through curriculum changes, program development, licensing issues, technology and communication. Therefore the Coalition representatives are diverse and include nursing education (community college, private college and university based programs), the hospital association, board of nursing, aging services association, and rural health.

This initiative is timely with the movement towards new health care delivery models within health care reform such as health care homes and accountable care organizations. AARP and RWJF were wise to focus on nursing to impact change in health care. Nurses encompass the greatest number of health care professions certainly in acute, public and long term care settings and as such they are the face of health care to Americans. In rural communities, with workforce shortages and the small staff size, it is imperative that nurses are able to practice to the extent of their education, have access to nursing education, and be prepared for leadership. Health professionals in small rural health care facilities are largely focused on primary care and practice without a fleet of medical residents and specialized advanced practice nurses and physicians, yet they are caring for the oldest and therefore the sickest patients as well as those with barriers to access such as culture, income, transportation, or language. In addition, many hospitals are staffed with nurses who are prepared at the associate degree level. As urban hospitals add access to baccalaureate education, rural hospitals needs the same access.

From my perspective, our Minnesota Action Coalition, although committed to the strategies including enhanced curriculum to increase the proportion of baccalaureate prepared registered nurses, has stumbled over governance structure and decision making. This stems from a lack of communication and leadership issues. Gaining consensus among nursing leaders is no small feat between an academic health center, state universities, private colleges and community colleges.  In order to establish a unified message, we need to build trust, support ongoing and open communication and focus on the goals. This is imperative in order to establish a unified message and collaborate to impact nursing practice, leadership and education. 

After my initial hesitation to participate in the MN Action Coalition, I’m now excited about the opportunity and appreciative of the expertise and support provided by AARP and RWJF to advance the Future of Nursing: Campaign for Action.

Tuesday, July 17, 2012

Strength In Numbers

Tracy Morton, Program Manager II

Strength In Numbers, the theme of this year’s National Conference of State Flex Programs, was clearly illustrated this past week in moving and motivational messages. The conference, held in Bethesda, Maryland, brought together the 45 state grantees of the Medicare Rural Hospital Flexibility (Flex) Programs to share their stories and hear from national experts on transforming quality improvement, building financial and operational improvement and supporting health system development for the 1,329 critical access hospitals (CAHs) throughout the country. The impact of the National Flex Program goes beyond the 1,329 communities where the CAHs reside to the other rural communities captured in the CAH’s market share, to the millions of Americans that call rural home and to even their suburban and urban families and friends who count on, and expect, quality health care for their loved ones. The 45 State Flex Programs individually and nationally impact this expectation. Talk about Strength In Numbers.

High quality health care in our country is becoming an expectation, evidenced by national initiatives such as Partnerships for Patients and the Medicare Beneficiary Quality Improvement Project (MBQIP). The federal government is also trying to control the cost of health care provision, as well as the cost of the health care system, with the coupling of quality and access to care through accountable care organizations (ACOs). While the hospitals need to be thinking about process and reporting changes for quality improvement, care transitions and patient accountability, they also need to think about moving from a volume-based to a value-based payment system. As Eric Shell from Stroudwater Associates pointed out, “rural hospitals need to think about the Triple Aim being played out in the market place, even when the market place doesn’t realize this is occurring”. Well, if this isn’t daunting, then I’m not sure what is.

The “message” at the conference wasn’t negative; it was inspirational. It was Strength In Numbers. It was about coming together; not trying to do the work alone. It was about sharing resources, best practices and stories; about being a catalyst for change and a change agent; thinking strategically about the State Flex Programs and the National Flex Program. The conference was about setting priorities and maximizing the impact of each of the 45 State Flex Programs on the 1,329 CAHs and their rural communities and partners. Because at the end of the day, and at the end of the conference, it came down to doing the right thing; about providing quality, affordable and accessible health care to the rural residents of America.

Friday, June 29, 2012

Beyond Traditional Healthcare: Creating Personally Connected Health

Kate Stenehjem, Information Specialist II

I found a lump. Palpable. Hard. Impossible to ignore. My gut told me to get it checked out right away. I didn’t even have to make an appointment because I was five months pregnant and scheduled to see my obstetrician the next week. On the day of my appointment I was sent to a nearby hospital for an ultrasound which quickly led to a biopsy. Due to the pregnancy, the tissue sample was difficult to diagnose so I was sent to another hospital. Once there, I had a mammogram and they repeated the ultrasound and the biopsy. Days felt like years waiting for the results. When the call finally came, they told me they were still uncertain about the pathology and needed to put me on a fast track for surgery.

I received high quality clinical care at all three facilities during this time. However, I couldn’t help but feel there was one crucial piece missing. Me. While making multiple phone calls each day to try to understand what was going on and physically transferring information back and forth between facilities across the state, all I really wanted was to be involved in my own care. Unfortunately, accessing my health information at this time proved to be incredibly difficult. This was a nightmare that I had to deal with for approximately two months but it left me wondering, “How do people with chronic health conditions deal with this lack of personal involvement in their own health care every day of their life?”

At the personal level, consumer engagement means being involved in your own health and health care which includes decisions about treatment. Engaged patients are powerful partners in their own health and health care. This involvement can lead to advocating for higher-value health care that is also more efficient and effective.

Studies indicate that engaged patients are more compliant which can ultimately lead to better outcomes. Therefore, patient engagement is a crucial part of the meaningful use of electronic health records. The Office of the National Coordinator for HIT (ONC) has outlined the following goals for consumer engagement:
  • Providing consumers with access to their health data
  • Making it easier for consumers to use their health information
  • Shifting attitudes about ownership of health data so physicians will be more willing to share data with patients and other health care providers
Stage 1 of meaningful use begins to set up a path that will result in consumer engagement with the requirement of providing clinical summaries for 50% of all office visits within three business days. The summary can be provided to the patient in either paper or electronic format. Phil Deering, REACH regional coordinator, noted, “The summary is the information that patients need to begin to take care of themselves, and it also provides a tool for the provider to review the information with the patient.”

“As we gather data, we can do health care by numbers, but it might not lower cost or make people healthier. Your health affects your whole life and quality of life. We now have the ability to look at patients as complete beings and not as just sets of numbers," noted Deering. “However, with today’s technology, patient access can flexible and bi-directional because we have the ability to expand the office visit through time. This is great, because now informed patients can begin to play a role as a partner in care, who can help make sure the record is accurate and up-to-date.”

We know that the after visit summary requirement of Stage 1 Meaningful Use is only a start on the journey consumers and providers need to travel. Changing provider and patient behavior is hard and will take time and effort. The good news is that as meaningful use results in patients getting better information, fewer people will feel as lost and desperate as I did during that difficult time a few years ago.