Monday, November 17, 2014

Celebrating Rural, Celebrating Access to Care!

By Rhonda Barcus, Program Specialist

Imagine the stress…your greatest loved one has received a cancer diagnosis which requires frequent treatments…four rounds of chemo and then seven weeks, five days a week of radiation. The closest service is over 80 miles round trip. In addition to the emotional and physical uncertainty of a cancer diagnosis, you are now dealing with the challenge of getting your loved one to treatment! I am celebrating today because that did NOT happen to me.

The first part is all true. My greatest loved one was diagnosed with cancer this summer, did go through four rounds of chemo, and has begun seven weeks, five days a week of radiation. We however, are so fortunate to live in a rural community that has a satellite center for cancer treatment. When she finished chemo and we began planning for radiation, we weren’t sure there were services available where we live. My loved one told me if we had to travel that distance every day, she would refuse further treatment.  I’m not sure she would have gone through with that, but I am glad we never had to make that decision.

This summer was a more difficult journey than we ever expected. What looked like a cut-and-dry diagnosis and treatment ended up being worse than expected. In the midst of the worry, I often stopped to be grateful. We had insurance; we had a car to get to treatments; and we had caring friends and family. And above all, I thought over and over how much harder the summer would have been if every treatment and every doctor visit required that 80 mile trip.

So today, during the week-long celebration of National Rural Health Day, I’m celebrating The Power of Rural. The “power” is profound. It’s not just about convenience and easy access, but at a deeper level, it can be about who not only survives, but also thrives.

Friday, October 31, 2014

Hospital Management in the Ever Changing World of Health Care

By Terry Hill, Senior Advisor for Rural Health Leadership and Policy

We all know that change is the new constant in healthcare. Many rural hospitals are considering options for aligning with other hospitals and/or health systems. Rural hospitals also face periodic changes in leadership and are challenged to find the right CEO. A good first step might be to identify a selection process or a model that has proven to be a best practice for others.

Recently, I interviewed Lynne Cunningham from Studer Group, who has just completed a successful assignment for a public hospital board in rural Alabama, which resulted in the successful identification of a new management partner for the hospital. The following are highlights from this conversation.

Q:  Today's healthcare leaders need an advanced level of skill to meet the continuous changes now so common in the industry. The future of organizations in healthcare relies heavily on making the right leadership choices to manage this environment. What steps should a board/executive team ponder when they realize they need a new approach to management? Would you consider your recent work a best practice?

A:  Good question. Yes, I would consider it a best practice. I think it’s important to “begin with the end in mind” as Stephen Covey would say. The board and executive team need to have serious conversations about the range of options they are willing to consider and the values which are important to them regardless of the choices they will entertain. I think there are four questions for the selection committee to consider:

  1. What results are you looking for?
  2. What type of individual are you looking for in a new executive?
  3. What culture do you want to promote?
  4. What values must an organization have if they are looking for a new management company?

Q:  How do you thoughtfully make the decision?

A:  There are some logical steps to take in making a thoughtful decision.

  • Organizational Assessment

This first step diagnoses your organization’s strengths, opportunities, vision and environment. During the assessment, your consultant will want to talk to executives, board members, community leaders, providers, hospital leaders, and employees. The deliverable from the organization assessment should be a research report with specific recommendations. These recommendations will make it easy to move to a job description for a new CEO or to a request for proposal (RFP) for a management company.

  • Prioritize Your Candidates

Review a side-by-side comparison of the proposals you receive. The proposals you’ll get (or the resumes for CEO candidates) will be long. It’s best to use a board created decision-making matrix, which prioritizes the key attributes for success that your organization is looking for, and compare candidates/proposers across these variables to prioritize those that meet your requirements.

  • Use Behavioral-Based Interviewing

Conduct telephone interviews with all viable candidates using behavioral-based questions that help you see how your candidate or proposing organizations have responded to a particular situation in the past. The best indicator of future performance is past performance! Send the interviewees additional questions in advance that need to be answered in these telephone conversations.

  • Update Your Side-by-Side Comparison

Continue to update the side-by-side comparison and then conduct in-person interviews with final candidates. Ask the candidates/proposers to focus their in-person presentations on critical factors that will be used to make the final decision.

  • Use the Decision-Making Matrix

The decision-making matrix will help you quantify your reaction to candidates or various management companies. As the final interviews are conducted, have each member of the selection team use the decision-making matrix as their guide for evaluation.

  • Select the Best Candidate/Company

By using the decision-making matrix, it typically will be clear which candidate/proposer is the best fit.

  • Gain Board Concurrence
Once the selection committee has agreed on their recommendation, gain board concurrence on this recommendation.

Q:  Okay, so the process to select a successful candidate/proposer has been completed. Isn’t that when the hard work really begins? How do you negotiate for success?

A:  You’re right, now we get the lawyers involved as you either:

  • Enter contract negotiations to finalize an employment contract for approval by the board, or
  • Enter contract negotiations and due diligence to finalize a management contract

If everyone has been engaged throughout the process, these negotiations are apt to proceed smoothly. Due diligence with a new management company may take 90 days or more, but contract negotiations and some transitions can occur simultaneously.

Q:  Is there anything else you’d consider a critical success factor?

A:  Yes, I think a well thought-out strategic communications plan is essential. It’s likely that a lot of internal and community stakeholders are aware that you are about to make a decision. Once the choice has been validated by the board, implement a comprehensive strategic communications plan to internal and external audiences. Control the message to the greatest extent possible. I’d suggest the plan include:

  • E-mail blast to employees and providers

Cascade the same message to all employees and providers to reduce variance in what your target audience is exposed to.

  • News release to the public

Transparently share information with the community and proactively position the “why” behind your action as a mission-driven decision.

  • Town hall meetings with employees and providers

The consistency of the message is maintained when employees and providers are hearing from the same executives in multiple meetings. In today’s electronic environment, one of the sessions can be videotaped and posted on the organization’s intranet. Unlike the e-mail blast, these town hall meetings provide an opportunity for employees and providers to ask questions and hear directly from those in leadership about how the change may impact work at the facility.

  • Community meeting open to the public

As a critical community resource, your community members will want to know about changes at their hospital or with their providers. Give them an opportunity to hear from executives and the board and to ask clarifying questions.

Yes, this is a lot of work, but I really think the planning and organization will pay off in support for your decision.

Monday, October 27, 2014

The Medicare Rural Hospital Flexibility Program Reaches Sweet 16

By Sally Buck, CEO

It is an exciting time for the Medicare Rural Hospital Flexibility (Flex) Program state grantees and partners as we recognize the program has reached its sweet 16, which is to say 16 years in existence. The Flex program was born as part of the Balanced Budget Act of 1997 to provide funding to states for the designation of critical access hospitals (CAHs) in rural communities and allows hospitals to be reimbursed on a reasonable cost basis for inpatient and outpatient services provided to Medicare patients. There are now 1,326 CAHs in the Flex program that play an essential role in sustaining rural health care.

The National Rural Health Resource Center (The Center) has the pride of a parent seeing their "child" reach this milestone of 16 years. Terry Hill, former Executive Director of The Center, was involved in the initial development of the Flex Program with the Federal Office of Rural Health Policy (FORHP) to support small rural hospitals in the conversions, development of networks, quality improvement and financial stabilization. Through a contract, The Center established an innovative technical assistance model: Technical Assistance and Services Center (TASC) in 1998 to provide information and education about Flex to the state grantees and their partners. 

In the infancy, TASC supported the states with development of rural health plans and creating "any necessary provider" rules, financial feasibility tools for assessing conversions. Through the toddler years, TASC provided state Flex grantees with education on cost reports, establishing networks for care transitions and quality improvement. It’s hard to imagine, but when we started, we didn’t have webinar technology, and the webpages were often static pages without search functions.

By the 10 year mark, the Flex program had moved into CAHs with swing beds to accommodate post acute care services. The "any necessary provider" rules reached their sunset, and conversions to CAH status dramatically declined. Flex programs and TASC mobilized to support CAHs to trauma designations through emergency medical services (EMS) and CAH training and regional planning. With a decade of experience, TASC, the Flex Monitoring Team (FMT) and state Flex programs worked together to provide CAHs with more data about the financial, quality and community engagement status within their state and nationally. Hospital Compare was launched by the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS), and although CAHs weren't required to report quality, hundreds of performance indicators became more important for all hospitals.

As the Flex program reached the awkward stage of the teenage years, the grantees adapted to new reporting requirements, and outcome-focused work plans. CAHs were watching the transformation of health care payment models evolve without a small volume option. A new initiative, the Medicare Beneficiary Quality Improvement Program (MBQIP) was introduced by FORHP in 2010 to increase quality reporting by CAHs with rural relevant measures and data to spur quality improvement efforts. This was a critical activity as CAHs were experiencing some bullying about their performance. With MBQIP, the Flex program has dramatically increased quality reporting by CAHs and states have implemented  a number of initiatives to improve patient safety, satisfaction and patient outcomes.

Now at 16 years of age, Flex is developing a vision of what it will become in the future as a mature program and what impact Flex, with over 1,300 CAHs, will have on rural health care in the U.S. and the thousands of communities served. With the changes in health care delivery and payment, the Flex Program needs to continue to share best practices, learn from peers and experts to ensure small rural hospitals can continue to improve care and the health of rural communities and reduce costs. Happy Sweet 16 to the Flex Program, and best wishes for many more successful years to come!



                                                                                                                          

Wednesday, October 8, 2014

Walk a Mile in your Funder's Shoes

By Margo Kulseth, Information Specialist



“Walk a mile in my shoes.” This familiar idiom was the advice given to an audience of rural health grantees, grantors and stakeholders in Kansas City, Missouri on September 30, 2014 at the Federal Grant Writing Workshop during the keynote session by Kim Moore, President of the United Methodist Health Ministry Fund. “In order to write a good grant application, we must think like the grant funder,” said Moore. What does the funder want to accomplish in awarding this money? What will motivate the funder to choose my application?

Kim Moore
Moore shared the following tips for grant seekers:

1. Consider the “lens” of the funder and write the application in those terms

  • What aspect of health care is the funder’s focus? Disparities? Social determinants? Social justice? Cultural competency?

2. Understand the rules and limitations of the grant

  • They can be complex and the same language may mean different things to different people

3. Do not fight the rules and limitations of the grant

  • Some of the limitations may seem unfair, but you are very unlikely to persuade the funder to change the grant

4. Do not assume your project is not what the funder is looking for

  • It may not be obvious at first glance, so dig deeper
  • Go to Grant Makers in Health at www.gih.org to find funders interested in health in your state or region

5. Respect the process laid out by the funder as you would like to be respected as the applicant or grantee

  • Do not go over someone’s head in an attempt to get funding

6. Give the information on a level your funder understands and needs

  • Do not be too brief so as to leave questions and doubts in the mind of the funder, but don't be facetious either
7. Show how you will leverage limited funds to create significant impact

  • The biggest challenge of philanthropy is creating positive change with limited resources
  • How will not completing your project be more costly in the long run?
8. Show how your project is likely to be sustainable beyond the term of the grant

  • Funders want to provide short term money that will have a long term impact (NOT vice versa)
  • Include a plan for how your project will continue once the money runs out (Hint: Do NOT say it will only continue by seeking other grant sources unless you have very likely ones in mind)
  • The purchase of equipment or training people how to do something new are good examples of sustainable use of grant funds

9. Show the funder the risk of investing in your project is likely to pay off with lessons learned that can be shared and used by others

10. Create a strong evaluation plan

  • How will you know your project is successful?

11. Create measurable outcomes

  • Do not over- or under-promise
  • Measurement should be commensurate with project scale
  • What is your cost per unit of service?
  • What is the quality of work?
  • Will people be healthier or happier because of your project?
  • The data should grow out of the work and inform the grantee of whether the project has been successful
  • Outcomes should be logical, appropriate and likely to occur
  • If XYZ happens, we will be happy about it and celebrate it

12. Have a dissemination plan for the project results

  • Are you going to write a report? Hold a webinar? Put the results on a website? Convene a conference or workshop?
  • Collaboration and sharing of lessons learned is one of the best ways to use grant funds wisely
  • Most problems cannot be solved in siloes
  • Bring all the stakeholders and their resources together for sharing

13. Point out the secondary benefits of the project

  • Will the project establish new working relationships? Develop a new and improved culture? Cross boundaries of traditional roles?

14. Include support letters from involved entities expressing their endorsement of your project if possible

  • Do not create such a negative picture of the need that you lose the opportunity
  • Balance the need description with the assets realistically available in the community

15. Discuss in advance how the grant award will be announced

  • Be careful to handle the process legally and within the guidelines of the funder

16. Become known by your funder beyond the written application

  • Get to know your funder personally if you can
  • Learn about each other

Mr. Moore told the audience, “Your work is more than a job. It’s a personal passion to advance the rural health system.” It is the same with funders. Most want to do more than give away money. They develop learning communities for grantees, hold webinars, conferences, workshops, provide technical assistance and generally want to see their grantees succeed and create positive change that can serve as examples for others to follow. Funders want partnership with and among their grantees.

The benefits of collaboration cannot be overstated. Grantees in the rural health arena or any other must align with and build on each other’s work. It is not just about getting and giving money. Success will come from aggregating resources, sharing, learning and disseminating together. Perhaps if we attempt to walk a mile in each other’s shoes, it will help us to appreciate and capitalize on our common goals for the greater good of improved rural health care.


Kim Moore presenting at the Federal Grant Writing Workshop in Kansas City, Missouri on September 30, 2014





Friday, September 26, 2014

RHPI: End of the Journey

by Terry Hill, Senior Advisor for Rural Health Leadership and Policy

Listening to Jerry Garcia this morning singing about a "long, strange trip," brought to mind the impending conclusion of our Rural Hospital Performance Improvement (RHPI) project journey in support of rural hospitals in the Mississippi Delta Region. Beginning with an initial hospital consultation in Tallahatchie County, Mississippi in 2000, the National Rural Health Resource Center (The Center) and its many partners supported 323 onsite hospital projects in eight states between 2001 and 2014, and put on hundreds of educational events.

Funding was provided by the Health Resources and Services Administration's (HRSA) Federal Office of Rural Health Policy (FORHP). We are grateful for their stellar leadership as well as the many contributions of our state partners, including state offices of rural health and state hospital associations. Our original corporate partner was the Mountain States Group, and our deep appreciation goes to their staff and to our stellar cadre of consultants too numerous to mention.

We have also had an amazingly dedicated staff here at The Center. They have worked hard to bring excellence to every aspect of the RHPI program, including measurable outcomes, education and customer service. And finally, we are grateful to the many hospital leaders in the Mississippi Delta Region that we have come to know and have proudly served over these many years. They are the real heroes of our journey, and their accomplishments have been documented by Dr. Eric Scorsone on three separate occasions, as returning $3, $11, and most recently $7 in hospital improvement, for every $1 invested in RHPI by the federal government.

In an era of value-based healthcare, we at The Center, are most proud of the documented value our RHPI program brought to more than 200 rural hospitals and the communities they serve. As we wrap up the RHPI project, we thought you might enjoy a few "fun facts" about the work done to support the Delta states:

  • From 2001 to 2014, RHPI supported 323 onsite hospital projects
  • Financial Operational Assessments were the most requested project with 110 completed
  • Strategic Planning was second most requested and 37 projects were supported
  • 170 different hospitals were eligible for onsite projects and 127 facilities took advantage of the opportunity
  • A Return on Community Investment (ROCI) analysis completed in 2014 indicated that for every $1 invested in RHPI, a return of $6.8 was generated 

Friday, September 19, 2014

Health IT In 2024: Time to put on your futurist hat!

By Joe Wivoda, Chief Information Officer

National Health IT Week 2014 has been a blast for me! I have blogged every day and tweeted about it as well @WivodaRural. I spoke with people in my community about the importance of patient portals and convinced quite a few people to sign up and access their health information. We even made signing up for a patient portal (or a family member’s) one of our wellness challenges at The Center! Life will be so much less exciting when HIT Week is over. Insert sad face here.

Regardless, this is the final HIT Week blog, and what is a blog series without a wild prediction for the future? I have been blathering on about how we are in the “bag phone” stage of HIT, and now it is time to imagine what life will be like when we are in the “iPhone” or “Android” stage of HIT. Well beyond Meaningful Use, when patient access to data is universal and expected. Data is easily shared among providers. Welcome to 2024!


Ten years from now, patient engagement will not be a buzz word, it will be just another way we access health care. Primary care visits will begin with accessing our mobile device. Thanks to interfaces with wearable devices such as watches and glasses, the provider can see our heart rate, temperature, Sp02, respiration, and other vital signs over the last several weeks. If we have a chronic condition, such as diabetes, there will be a near-constant monitoring of our blood glucose levels. Since this information can be stored indefinitely (storage is essentially limitless) and computing power is significantly greater than today (Moore’s law will have broken down, but still…) most providers will be notifying their patients when the data indicates that there may be a problem. No longer will we need to call the clinic, they will call us when our data indicates there may be something wrong.

Telemedicine will be commonplace. What we may call an “e-visit” today will just be a “visit” to the provider. Primary and specialty visits will utilize technology that is at our fingertips to provide the right care at the right time, and most often at the patient’s home or office. Simple, inexpensive peripherals will be able to monitor our vitals and likely be able to perform common lab tests. Imagine doing your own urinalysis in the “comfort” of your home.

Apps on your smartphone will be able to utilize powerful centralized systems like IBM's “Watson” to diagnose complex diseases. Already apps like iTriage can be very useful for simple diagnoses, so imagine where we will be in 10 years!

A few years ago, a futurist told me that we might be 10 years away from having a “tricorder” from Star Trek: A device that can be held up to a person that can “sense” what physical disorders may exist. There is now an X Prize for just such a device, so I expect in 10 years that invasive testing will be rare. Instead we will walk in a “phone booth” (Remember those? They are collectible now.) that will analyze our vitals and other things to determine what ails us.

This is a long way from where we are in 2014. Consider that the cores of most of our EHRs were written 20 years ago or more, so we do have a long way to go. Increased data analytics, more complete data capture, and huge data repositories that include DNA data will be required in the future. This isn't science fiction; we are well on the way to be able to do these things. In fact, I am probably being much less imaginative than I could be. What do you think National HIT Week 2024 will be like?

Thursday, September 18, 2014

Rural is Not Small Urban: Issues in Rural HIT

By Joe Wivoda, Chief Information Officer

Recently, someone asked me what I thought the major issues were with Health Information Technology (HIT) in rural hospitals and clinics. I get this question quite often, and I realized I have never blogged on this before! Since it is National HIT Week, and I am blogging daily, what better time is there to blog about rural issues? Some of these barriers apply to urban facilities but are amplified in rural, kind of like in an urban yard, you might expect to see a push mower, while in my yard, there is a Ford tractor. Or something like that. My metaphors have been weak lately.

Workforce

Access to qualified HIT staff is still an issue in many rural areas. Networks and systems typically have HIT staff, but many CAHs and Rural Health Clinics (RHCs) make do with a local personal computer consultant or someone who has some basic troubleshooting skills. It is rare to have a skilled HIT person working at a standalone CAH or RHC, but when there is, the facility is typically far ahead of those without HIT talent.

It can be the same issue for clinical HIT staff. When the electronic health record (EHR) is put in, there usually will be some sort of “super user” that needs to be assigned. They are responsible for implementation and internal support moving forward. Most CAHs and particularly RHCs can’t afford to have someone partially dedicated to maintain and support the clinical side of the EHR, so a talented nurse who is the super user will often need to step back into nursing full time, and the EHR gets neglected.

Cost of Upgrades

Particularly this year, with the new Meaningful Use certified technology requirements, EHR upgrades have been very expensive. I am aware of several CAHs who have had to pay more than $200,000 to implement the 2014 versions of their EHRs. Additionally, many of these upgrades require re-implementation of several core features, like computerized physician order entry (CPOE). The new rule allowing delays in Stage 2 does not apply if you merely can’t afford it. This can be a difficult expense to justify, particularly when the financial incentives are coming to an end.

Transitions of Care

I have written about this in a couple of other blogs. Of all of the Meaningful Use Stage 2 measures, I feel this is the most important for making a difference in the communities we serve. Patients need this, and our referral partners are begging for this!

The Stage 2 requirements around transitions of care and summary of care records has been difficult for rural facilities. Many of them do not fully understand their referral patterns, which is a critical step. Also, many CAH referral partners are either not eligible for meaningful use and do not have the capability to receive continuity of care documents (CCDs) (long term care, home care/hospice) or they are not interested/motivated to work with the CAH/RHC to exchange the information (urban tertiary/quaternary hospitals and specialists). To achieve the stage 2 measures, it will be necessary to overcome these hurdles, but more importantly, it is the right time to solve the problem of poor information flow for referrals. We are harming patients every day by not solving this!

Clinical Quality Measures

Generating electronic Clinical Quality Measures is difficult even when you have qualified HIT staff, and with the workforce shortage in HIT/Clinical IT at most rural facilities, this can be nearly impossible. It isn’t that they just need someone who can extract the data either, because it is typical that either the data is not collected, or it is not collected in a uniform manner. The act of attempting to generate clinical quality measures electronically will always result in process improvement opportunities. Just take a look at how your facility is collecting smoking status. I bet it is being collected in multiple fields and may not even be discrete. Now try doing a report on falls…

ICD-10 Preparation

ICD-10 is coming. Most CAHs and RHCs have done little about this, and if they have, it is just the training of providers and coders. There is much more HIT work to do prior to converting to ICD-10, including testing with payers and interface testing. Now would be a good time for me to plug our ICD-10 Toolkit. Free to download!

Health Reform Preparation

Rural health has been slow to understand and implement technology to support health reform. In particular Health Information Exchange (HIE), data repositories and reporting technologies are not in place or being considered. This goes back to workforce and also awareness of the implications of moving from volume to value. Health reform is here; our payment models will be changing; and HIT is a core foundation piece for being able to operate under the new models.

These are a few of my thoughts. No, the sky is not falling. Yes, we can remove these barriers. It just takes some focus and new ways of working. That isn't easy, but we need to make the changes to survive and thrive in a world where the rules are changing rapidly.

Speaking of rapid change, tomorrow is my last blog entry for HIT Week, and it will be a doozy! I will be putting on my futurist cap and discussing what HIT will look like in the next several years. Tweet me @WivodaRural, and give me some of your thoughts. This will be fun!